FPGeeks ScoreCard Platinum Plaisir

Review Specificaitons

Platinum Plaisir Fountain Pen Review-1 copy

 

Pen Class: Economy ($25 and under)
Street Price:: $21.00

Body Material: Aluminum
Nib Material: Steel
Nib Size: Fine (.03mm) and Medium (.05mm)
Cap Type: Slip Cap (Snap On/Off)
Post-able: Yes
Filling Mechanism: Cartridge (Proprietary) or Converter (Proprietary)
Ink Capacity: 1.0 ml / 0.033 oz
Overall Weight: 19 g / 0.67 oz
Cap Weight: 10 g / 0.35 oz
Body Weight: 9 g / 0.32 oz
Overall Length Capped: 143 mm / 5.63 in
Overall Length Posted: 157 mm / 6.18 in
Body Length (not including nib): 107 mm / 4.22 in
Nib Length: 14 mm / 0.55 in
Body Length (including nib): 121 mm / 4.77 in
Cap Diameter w/o Clip: 14 mm / 0.55 in
Cap Diameter w/Clip: 16 mm / 0.63 in
Body Diameter at Section: 12 mm / 0.47 in
Body Diameter at Posting End: 11 mm / 0.43 in

If this pen were a movie, it would be…

In a Metal Mood (1996)

Review Dealer Prep

Dan: 1 - With the name for a pen that means ‘pleasure’ in French, I certainly didn’t get much pleasure from the way this pen was presented. The Platinum Plaisir comes in a clear cellophane wrapper with a tag attached to the clip. Platinum certainly isn’t wasting time or money on the packing of this low end pen. I guess they save that for their limited editions. I really don’t mind them skimping on the packaging as long as what they save goes back into the pen. Hopefully that’s the case here.

Eric: 0 - I cannot bring myself to give the Plaisir even a single point with regard to Dealer Prep because, in my mind, there is no Dealer Prep. As you say, Dan, the pen comes in a clear cellophane bag-type wrapper that’s just large enough to hold the pen. For a pen that’s near the top of the price point for it’s class (Economy Class, $25 and under), I expected more than a cellophane wrapper.

Review Filler Up

Platinum Plaisir Fountain Pen Review-2-FillerUp

Dan: 6 - The Platinum Plaisir uses the cartridge/converter filling system. If you’ve read any of our reviews thus far you’ll know I’m not fan of c/c’s. Platinum isn’t going to gain any points with me by using a proprietary system, either. While their cartridges do hold more ink than an international cartridge and their converters are arguably nicer than others, you’re still limited to whatever Platinum has to offer. And the converter doesn’t even come with the pen. It’s a $7 option that actually pushes this pen into the next class, so to keep it in the Economy class we’re reviewing it without the converter.

The cartridge is a bit more interesting than most others, though. Most cartridges have a plastic seal that you have to break when pushing it onto the pen. The Platinum cartridge has a small metal ball in the end that seals it and when it’s been inserted onto the pen you can hear the ball rattle inside the cartridge. It might be annoying to some, but I kind of like it. Also, when inserting the cartridge, it has the most satisfying “CLICK!” I’ve ever heard. I knew immediately that the cartridge was fully seated.

Eric: 2 - I toyed with the idea of giving this pen a slightly higher score in this category because there is a converter available. Unfortunately, the converter is not included with the pen and it’s proprietary. What I’m left with is a cartridge-only pen that uses proprietary cartridges and does not provide room for a spare in the barrel.

Dan, I agree that the Platinum cartridge is more interesting than any other I’ve seen or used. The metal ball that seals the cartridge before use is unique and oddly appealing. The hearty “click” of a successful cartridge installation is helpful as I often wonder whether a cartridge is correctly in place and ready. However, the rattling of the now liberated metal ball inside the cartridge is quite bothersome and reminds me of the sound you hear when shaking a can of spray paint.

Review Test Drive

Platinum Plaisir Fountain Pen Review-3-Test Drive

Dan: 6.5 – My first impression of this pen is that it seems a little cheap for how much it actually cost. I don’t know if it’s because I’m staring at the same nib and feed that’s in my $4 Platinum Preppy or if it’s because of how light it is, or what. I just get a cheap vibe from this pen. However, I do prefer the aluminum cap and body over the plastic pieces on the Preppy.

I inserted the cartridge and when I came back to it after an hour it was ready to write. Initially, the flow seemed a bit dry but I never had any issues with hard starts or skipping. The nib was smooth with a lot of feedback but never scratchy. It was also soft and springy but there’s definitely no flex. I wouldn’t say the Test Drive was good or bad, just kinda “meh”.

Eric: 6 - The pen, being aluminum, is lighter than it looks. Since quality is often associated with heft, the Platinum Plaisir makes a less than ideal first impression. However, it certainly performs nicely. Once the cartridge had been installed and the pen was ready, the Test Drive as a breeze. The ink flow is spot on. I experienced one hard start but no skipping. The pen kept up the pace very nicely.

The nib cannot be described as butter-smooth, but it’s not scratchy. There is feedback but no clawing of the paper. What’s interesting, however, is that the nib sounds like it should be scratchy. There is a lot of audio coming from this pen and I believe the aluminum barrel is somehow acting like a small echo chamber, amplifying the sound of the nib on paper. Having the audio of a scratchy nib while enjoying the feel of a nib that is smooth is oddly confusing, like seeing someone nodding yes while saying no.

Review Under the Hood

Dan: 6.5 – If you’ve seen the nib on a Platinum Preppy then you’ve seen the nib on the Platinum Plaisir. It’s a small steel nib that matches the color of the pen and has Platinum’s “p” logo and the nib width stamped into it. You can also see the feed and its many fins through the clear section.

Like I said in the Test Drive, the nib is smooth but with a lot of feedback. As in, it’s like someone smoothed the nib using 1000 grit polishing paper. So it’s smooth, but rough as well. However you’d describe it, you certainly can’t say it’s scratchy because it’s not at all.

Eric: 5.75 - I don’t usually care for the look of a nib with folded “wings,” but it somehow works for the Plaisir. The nib’s shape adds to the pen’s modern look. I particularly enjoy the fact that the nib’s color matches the pen. The stamps of both the logo and the nib number are unobtrusive and do not deter from the sleekness of the design. It’s a steel nib, which is perfectly in line with a pen of the Economy Class, and it’s surprisingly capable. I find the level of feedback too high, even on Rhodia paper, but if you enjoy feedback (without scratchiness), you’ll love this nib.

Review Performance

Dan: 6 – I mentioned in the Test Drive that the flow seemed to be a bit dry and I continued to notice that up until about half way through the Road Trip. As I was using it I could see the feed start to become saturated. Once it was fully saturated the flow improved enough to bring it back into my comfort zone. If you do purchase a Plaisir please keep this in mind because it can totally change your experience.

Eric: 6.5 - I found the Platinum Plaisir’s performance to be quite admirable. Unlike you, Dan, I did not notice any sort of flow problem once the pen sat for an hour after having the cartridge installed. The pen puts ink to paper where I ask and when I ask. It’s very compliant and easy going. As you’ll read in the Road Trip, I had only one hesitant start and no skipping.

Review Design Notes

Platinum Plaisir Fountain Pen Review-6-Design Notes

Dan: 7.75 - I really like the design of the Platinum Plaisir. It’s a decently sized pen with large radius ends and a fairly low profile clip. It’s available in 7 different colors with the nib and the middle of the clip matching the color of the pen. The thick, one piece cap band has “Platinum Japan” and “Plaisir” molded into it and are separated by 5 interlocking circles.

The cap itself is also pretty interesting. Not the outside, obviously, but what’s on the inside. The inside of the cap has been redesigned so that it seals the nib so well that it can be capped for a year and still write without any issues. That’s a pretty bold claim but Platinum says that they’ve tested it with the results to prove it.

Eric: 7.5 - I agree, Dan, there is much to admire about the thoughtfulness of design that went into the Plaisir. The one major flaw to my eyes is the size of the cap band. It is overwhelmingly large and “in your face” when looking at the pen. With all other design details about the pen executed so well, I just can’t understand how this eyesore of a cap band made it from initial mockup to final product. Take the top and bottom portions of the cap band away, leaving only an unadorned band with the maker’s marks, and you’ve got something that is classy and falls right in line with the rest of the pen’s modern look.

Get past the cap band, however, and you’ll find all the wonderful details that Dan has mentioned. The size is both pleasing and comfortable. The detail of the clip that matches the color of the pen is a very nice touch. The production of 7 different colors means that the majority of users should be able to find one favorite. The “newly designed structure” inside the cap which prevents ink from drying for up to a year is a nice feature if you happen to be looking for a pen that you will leave inked and abandoned for long periods of time. I hope to never need such a pen, but I’m glad to know that the Plaisir exists just in case.

Review Detailing

Platinum Plaisir Fountain Pen Review-5-Detailing

Dan: 8.5 - The Platinum Plaisir is build like a brick wall. The barrel and section screw together to create one solid unit and the cap snaps into place with authority. The cap also posts securely. I even whipped the pen back and forth several times just to test it and the cap didn’t budge.

The anodized aluminum cap and body are supposedly scratch resistant due to their Pearl Processing Treatment. I don’t know if that’s what they call the anodizing process or if it’s an entirely different treatment, but if it makes the pen any more scratch resistant then I’m all for it.

Eric: 7 - I find the detail in the design build of the Platinum Plaisir to be very good indeed, equal to that of the Sheaffer VFM. The Plaisir is as solid an aluminum pen you could hope to create. The nib’s number (in this case, 03) is stamped into the very top of the cap. I tried to ignore this, but I find it distracting, not to mention unnecessary.

It’s nice to know that the anodized aluminum cap and body are scratch resistant. I tested the scratch resistance with a few different abrasive-ish objects and found that nothing left a mark. Unfortunately, dent resistance is not built in to the pen. Without much effort and on the very first attempt, I easily placed a small dent in the body of the pen. It’s so small that you’d have to know it’s general location to even begin to look for it, but it’s there.

Review 21 Minute Road Trip

Dan: 6.5 - There was nothing really special about the Road Trip with the Plaisir. It wasn’t bad, which is good, but nothing really stood out about the pen. It performed about as well as you could hope for a fountain pen. The Plaisir is large enough to be comfortable, which I was very thankful for but the section is very slippery, especially if there’s even the tiniest bit of moisture on your hands. While using it I never experienced any issues such has hard starts or skipping.

Eric: 6 - The Platinum Plaisir’s girth makes it fairly comfortable when writing for longer periods. My hand didn’t utter the dreaded, “Are we there yet?” until the 20 minute marker, which is very good. The experience of writing with the Plaisir can best be described as ordinary. The pen does it’s job and behaves well, but does not leave a lasting memory in the mind of the user. In the full twenty-one minutes, I experienced one hesitant start and no skipping what-so-ever. Very much out of character for me, I posted the Plaisir because the pen was much more balanced that way.

Review The Checkered Flag

Pros:
- 7 Different Colors
- Construction & Quality

Cons:
- Proprietary Cartridges / Proprietary Converter
- Basically an Aluminum Bodied Preppy

Famous Last Words:

Dan: I don’t think you would be making a bad choice if you picked the Platinum Plaisir. While there are certainly many worse choices, you’d be hard pressed to find more than a few better ones in this price range. It would really come down to personal preference and which aspects of a pen matter most. If you like a good sized pen with lots of color options and great detailing then take a look at this pen. If you can’t stand proprietary filling systems and need an awesome nib you should probably look elsewhere.

Eric: The Platinum Plaisir is definitely a top of the line Economy Class pen. In my mind, if the overly large cap band doesn’t offend your sense of balance and design, then this pen should be on your short list.

Platinum Plaisir Fountain Pen Review-7


Other Platinum Plaisir reviews from around the web:
Note Booker, Esq.
Pocket Blonde
Office Supply Geek


This pen was purchased for review.

Tagged with →  
Share →
  • Jason

    Nice review. Still hard to pay $20 for a Preppy (which I like). But I bit the bullet and got one for a more durable pen. In two days, the inner sleeve that the feed screws into came out of the barrel. Haven't really looked to fix it.

  • Maja

    I own several Platinum Preppy fountain pens and *never* had a problem with start-up issues. Having said that, I did have a barrel crack on me when I (presumably) over-tightened it after changing cartridges…so the idea of a similar pen with a metal body (vs. plastic) appeals to me.

    Thanks for the review!

    • http://fpgeeks.com/ Dan Smith

      Sometimes pens just don't like Eric. I bet it's the accent. ;-)

  • Ryan @ Brassing

    Great review, guys! Wholehearted agreement from me on just about every point. The one thing that I've noticed about this pen is that the grey finned piece is very prone to cracking, especially if used with the rollerball tip. Have you seen any evidence of this on your review pieces yet? (Dan, I'd meant to bring it up over dinner the other night but it slipped my mind.)

    • http://fpgeeks.com/ Dan Smith

      We didn't get the rollerball tip with this pen. I think it only comes with the Preppy when you buy one of those big honkin' bottles of ink.

  • Cavbaby4life

    Loved the review, and now i'm convinced that I should leave the platinum plaisir alone. Will yall do a review of the Sailor Clear Candy Pens? It's not bad for $16.50. Even though it feels cheap and skips on occasion it's pretty smooth. I wonder if yall have seen of this guys video reviews of fountain pens http://www.youtube.com/user/sbrebrown/videos?sort

    • http://fpgeeks.com/ Dan Smith

      We don't have any plans to review the Sailors but it can always be added to our list.
      Btw, thanks for the youtube link.

    • Maja

      Stephen's YouTube pen & ink reviews are *great*—highly recommended!

  • Antonietta

    Meh. I'm always looking for inexpensive pens to carry around with me in my pocket. This one doesn't really appeal to me. Seems like there are better options in its price point. Haven't been impressed with preppies so I'll definitely pass.

  • http://monkeyphotomcr.blogspot.com/ John the Monkey

    Have to agree with Antonietta here, something about it just doesn't grab me.

    Here in the UK, RRP is £14.95, which makes it a competitor on price with Parker jotters, Schneider Bases – add a couple of quid and you can pick up a Safari or Vista.

    I guess the selling point is the aluminium body – with the demise of the Jotter flighter, I can't think of another metal bodied pen at the same rrp.

  • Steven Horvat

    I like the preppy pens the body and the comfort of holding is nice. I also like how it can be converted to an eyedropper pen. I don't like the nib and I really wish it was updated to something better for the Plaisir pen with something better.

  • Jolanda

    If you buy the converter there’s a little black adapter included.
    If you click it where the cartridge or converter goes you can use international cartridges or converters in this pen.