Susanna at Giardino keeps filling up my inbox with stuff I have a hard time resisting. Since I'm posting a review, clearly she got me again...
I was on the fence when I first saw them online, but I did like the cracked acrylic pattern and colors of the brown and red models. Then I saw the price... 80 euros? The exchange rate is essentially 1:1? *sigh* Add to basket and checkout. An impulse gift for me and my wife.
They arrived today, and I don't think they're bad looking at all.
The nib seems a little small proportionately (exaggerated here by the angle), but I'll just call it "vintage"
Size is about the same as a Pelikan M600. It's very comfortable for me, although I would prefer if the section were a bit thicker. The barrel will hold a standard converter (strangely not included), and it will also hold a long international cartridge.
The biggest question is the build quality, and there is a spirited discussion in the Italian sub forum. I think it's acceptable/good, but not great. In fairness, this pen is only $80 though. It does feel hearty though, and not fragile.
The clip is quite sturdy, although I don't expect the plating to last (any of the plating, for that matter). If you look closely, you can see that there is some discrepancy in dimensions. This is also the case with the ring and black end of the barrel.
The Phillips screw holding the cap, inner cap and clip is a little clumsy - but utilitarian.
Here's a shot of the nib. It's a simple friction fit into the section, and measures 5.34mm in diameter. It should be able to be swapped with a #5 JoWo or Bock. Visually, it's unremarkable (and yes, I've already stubbed it). Tandania mentioned that she didn't understand why they didn't use their standard steel nib. I agree and it baffles me too. I don't see any real cost savings here.
But at the end of the day, it's a pen. This is where it really comes into its own. That cheap looking little nib is actually a great writer. The tines are uniform and the flow is generous. I did pull and clean them, but made no adjustment (other than the grind on mine). They're very smooth with just a slight hint of feedback. I had a hard time getting the wife's back long enough to take a picture and write a line or two for this review.
Overall, I like it and it's nice to have a decent looking pen (that writes well) that I can throw in a bag and not worry about like I would an "expensive" pen. I think it was worth the spend. Your mileage may vary.
Bookmarks