Another early contender was iKonPen. I haven't been able to find out when it first appeared but this is the way that it looked back on October 9, 1999:
iKonPen1999oct9.png
Three things about this site:
First of all, there are no "y"s in the text. I don't believe it was like this originally so apparently this seems to be a glitch in the Wayback software.
Second, there is a "iKonTalk" section that apparently led to a connected bulletin board system. I haven't been able to find a copy of that BBS page. However this "webpage-BBS combo" will become popular for future websites... including FPG.
Third, the site had an onboard magazine known as "iKonZine" for reviews and essays:
iKonZine1999oct9.png
Bookmarks