Ukraine extends battlefield gains as Kremlin reels from setback
By Isabelle Khurshudyan, Steve Hendrix, Dan Lamothe, Emily Rauhala and David L. Stern
Updated September 12, 2022 at 5:17 p.m. EDT|Published September 12, 2022 at 2:57 p.m. EDT
An abandoned Russian armored personnel carrier in a village on the outskirts of Izyum. (Juan Barreto/AFP/Getty Images)
KYIV, Ukraine — Blue-and-yellow flags were raised in more liberated towns and villages in northeast Ukraine on Monday, as the stunning counteroffensive that pushed Russia into a messy retreat boosted optimism at home and abroad over a potential turning point in the war, and renewed international calls to send Ukraine more weapons in hopes of hastening Russia’s defeat.
The lightning push by Ukrainian forces, in which they recaptured in a matter of days nearly all of the Kharkiv region occupied since the early days of the war last winter, left Moscow reeling. Despite the setback, the Kremlin and its proxies insisted that the war would go on until President Vladimir Putin’s goals are achieved, and they blamed NATO and the United States for Ukraine’s refusal to surrender.
The Ukrainian military said Monday that in the previous 24 hours it had advanced into an additional 20 towns and villages that had been under Russian control — claims that could not be independently verified. On Sunday, Ukraine’s commander in chief, Gen. Valery Zaluzhny, said his forces had retaken more than more than 3,000 square kilometers, 1,100 square miles, in less than a week.
U.S. defense officials declined to specify how far they think Ukrainian forces can push, citing concerns about operational security. But it was likely just a “matter of time” before the collapse, considering Russia’s long-running struggles in organizing, equipping and sustaining its forces on the battlefield and Ukraine’s accumulation of high-power weapons provided by the West, said one of the officials, speaking on condition of anonymity under ground rules set by the Pentagon. Still, U.S. officials assessed, the war remains a tough fight for the Ukrainians that could stretch out for a long time.
In their hasty retreat, spun by Russia’s Defense Ministry as a “regroup,” the Russians abandoned tanks, armored vehicles and ammunition that Ukraine plans to refashion and use on the battlefield. Posting a video of an fully-intact Russian howitzer, a Ukrainian official joked on Twitter that the Ukrainian “military accepted its first lend lease supplies from Russia” in the liberated city of Izyum.
Russia still occupies large swaths of eastern and southern Ukraine, including cities like Mariupol and Kherson, Putin’s coveted “land bridge” to Crimea, which Russia annexed illegally in 2014, and most of the Luhansk and Donetsk regions where Russia has recognized two self-declared separatist “republics.”
[Police officers sort unexploded mine shells and weapons after their return from the village of Udy, which was recently liberated from Russian occupation, in the Kharkiv region of Ukraine. (Gleb Garanich/Reuters)]
Military analysts, however, said that the equipment losses could be a significant blow to Russia — and that Ukraine will use its recent success to lobby for even more security assistance.
Amid Ukraine’s startling gains, liberated villages describe Russian troops dropping rifles and fleeing
In recent weeks, Ukrainian officials had been worried about support from Western partners eroding ahead of U.S. elections that could shift control to the Republicans in Congress and what’s expected to be a difficult and expensive winter in Europe because of spiking energy prices tied to the war. But some Western allies have called to provide Ukraine with more powerful weapons.
Lithuanian Foreign Affairs Minister Gabrielius Landsbergis tweeted Sunday that “all stockpiles of western advanced armaments,” including long-range missiles, fighter jets and tanks, “must be made available to Ukraine.” Western nations have so far held back from providing those.
“Let me be frank,” Landsbergis wrote. “It is now beyond doubt that Ukraine could have thrown Russia out months ago if they had been provided with the necessary equipment from day one.”
Ukrainian Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba said on Twitter that the E.U.'s top diplomat, Josep Borrell, called him to “express his admiration and respect for Ukraine’s defense forces as they liberate more territories from Russian occupation.”
“He explored further ways for the E.U. to help Ukraine and bring peace closer. I requested weapons, sanctions, and financial aid,” Kuleba said. Borrell recently warned that weapons stocks in E.U. countries were running low — “depleted in a high proportion,” he said — because of donations to Ukraine.
In Moscow, the retreat exposed fissures among Kremlin loyalists.
Chechen leader Ramzan Kadyrov said he might have to speak with Putin himself because he didn’t trust that Putin is receiving the bad news from his advisers. Pro-Russian military bloggers have sharply criticized the government for not mobilizing more soldiers for the fight — a move that Putin has sought to avoid because conscriptions could risk turning public support against the war.
On Monday, officials reiterated that the aims of the “special military operation” — the Kremlin term for the war — would be accomplished regardless of the setbacks, though the precise aims have never been fully clear. At first, Putin was intent on capturing Kyiv and toppling the government, but that failed.
“The goals of the special military operation will be achieved,” Nikolai Patrushev, the secretary of the Russian Security Council said on Monday in Kemerovo at a meeting in the Siberian Federal District. “The events around Ukraine show that the United States and its vassals are trying to prolong the conflict in Ukraine by increasing the supply of weapons and military equipment, which is later used against civilians.”
Russia appeared to respond to Ukraine’s counteroffensive with retaliatory missile strikes on critical civilian infrastructure on Sunday night, plunging several regions, including Kharkiv, into darkness as the power went out. Pentagon officials said there had been a notable increase in missile strikes over the weekend.
Kremlin propagandist Margarita Simonyan, the editor in chief of the government-funded TV channel RT, formerly Russia Today, cheered the attacks, adding on social media that “electricity is a privilege.”
Russian troops in big retreat as Ukraine offensive advances in Kharkiv
But the mood around Ukraine remained jubilant and defiant on Monday.
On social media, people reposted Ukraine President Volodymyr Zelensky’s statement directly addressing the Russians, saying that, “cold, hunger, darkness and thirst are not as scary and deadly for us as your ‘friendship and brotherhood.’ ”
The euphoria seemed only to harden Ukraine’s position that it will not surrender an inch of territory to Russia, and is intent on reclaiming land, including Crimea, that has been occupied since 2014. Zelensky reiterated on Sunday night that Ukraine was not prepared to negotiate with Russia because it had yet to formulate any acceptable offers.
Volodymyr Fesenko, director of the Penta, Center of Applied Political Studies in Kyiv, said the military successes were “a signal to exactly those Western politicians who are wavering,” who fear that providing weapons could lead to a dangerous escalation in the conflict. The gains have also expanded the Ukrainian government’s own ambitions for eventual peace talks, he said.
“I think that strengthening the military positions in Ukraine means strengthening the diplomatic positions of our country,” Fesenko said.
Advertisement
U.S. officials have said that it is up to Ukrainian officials if and when they choose to broker an end to the war with Russia. But some of Ukraine’s Western partners are concerned that the Russian setbacks, combined with Zelensky’s refusal to make concessions, could escalate the conflict and even prompt Putin to use a tactical nuclear weapon.
“The West should be very clear now that crossing those lines could bring NATO much more aggressively into the conflict,” said Jim Stavridis, a retired U.S. admiral and former supreme allied commander of NATO.
“While the odds of fully expelling the Russians from all of Ukraine are long, the job of the West should be to give them what they need to be in the strongest possible position to negotiate — something that appears months away,” Stavridis said.
Maintaining the recently reclaimed territory will now be the challenge for Ukraine. The eastern Kharkiv region borders Russia and the city of Kharkiv, which was Ukraine’s second-largest before the war, remains in range of Russian multiple launch rocket systems even if fired from Russian territory.
On Monday, after the recent dizzying run of victories, at least some Ukrainian soldiers stole a few hours to rest, stock up on snacks and celebrate.
In Chuhuiv, a city east of Kharkiv, the pickup trucks, panel vans and SUVs — hastily painted camo green and donated from around Europe — came and went from the small grocery store.
Fighters came out with bread and candy bars and bottles of soda, many wearing broad grins and some exchanging chest hugs when they passed each other.
“We feel fantastic,” said one, apologizing for not having time to talk as hurried to jump in a buddy’s car. “We have momentum.”
Chuhuiv, a gateway to the stretch of liberated villages east of Kharkiv — Ukraine’s second largest city — is at the edge of Ukraine’s intact cellphone network and many of the soldiers were taking advantage of an internet opportunity. A bearded soldier leaned back on a bench talking on his phone, wearing a look of contented fatigue.
Misha, a member of the 14th Brigade who said he couldn’t give his last name, scrolled on his phone outside of a store selling military wear. Even the soldiers were stunned, he said, by the progress of the counteroffensive.
One young Ukrainian soldier’s death felt by family, friends and country
“We’ve made it all the way to the Russian border so it’s time to breathe a bit, wait for the next orders,” Misha said.
His unit helped liberate a village that has been occupied since the very first days of the invasion. The men are still based there, giving them a chance to see some residents return to the homes for the first time in seven months, even though some areas are still laced with mines and unexploded ordnance.
“They are thrilled to come home, and they are so grateful to us,” said Misha, 50. “But one man waved us over to show us a rocket in his yard that hadn’t blown up.”
By Monday night, Ukrainian forces had advanced deeper into the Donetsk and Luhansk regions — photos of Ukrainian flags raised in Bohorodychne and Sviatohirsk, on the banks of the Siverskyi Donets River, were widely circulated on social media.
The military also claimed to recapture about 195 square miles of territory in the south of the country and to liberate five settlements as part of a counteroffensive in the past two weeks, but the gains could not be independently verified.
Though Ukraine had hyped a coming counteroffensive in the south to take back the port city of Kherson, its simultaneous push around Kharkiv evidently took the Russians by surprise. Russia reinforced its positions in Kherson, and Ukraine’s gains there have been slower. The Ukrainian military has restricted media access to the region.
Western military experts said they were impressed by Ukraine’s success.
“It needs to be highlighted what a great job the Ukrainians have done controlling information — their operational security,” said retired U.S. Army Lt. Gen. Ben Hodges, a former commander of U.S. Army Europe.
“We know a lot more about what is happening on the Russian side. The fact the Ukrainians were able to move troops and equipment to the north when the Russians looked to the south that’s really, really good,” he said.
“For Russia, this is a culminating point,” Hodges said. “They ran out of steam back in August. They could not continue offensive operations. The Ukrainians saw this and began preparations months ago.”
Hendrix reported from Chuhuiv, Ukraine, Lamothe from Washington, Rauhala from Brussels and Stern from Kyiv. Robyn Dixon in Riga, Latvia, and Missy Ryan and Karen DeYoung in Washington contributed to this report.
Re: Ukraine outrage and analysis.
Originally Posted by Chip
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks