Subforum history

[TSherbs]

... While I'm not suggesting TSherbs and EoC are the same person,....

Yeah, that would lower your batting average.

But I asked you about your public speculation (more than once) about Warbler as EOC.

Why spend this time explaining history to EOC when he would know it all already? Have you let go of your speculation that Warbler is EOC in disguise? Last you addressed this directly, you said that you were still waiting for Warbler to slip up.

Why do you obsess over constructing these narratives,

The "narrative" of asking you if you still believe the assertion that you made quite recently about the identity of a poster active here on this thread? That "narrative"?

You don't usually duck straightforward, easy questions, dneal. But how you post is your prerogative.

Warbler is either EOC in disguise, and thus knows everything that you are talking about already, or he is not. No in betweens in this case.

[dneal]

The "narrative" is a construction of yours that has no bearing on reality. You construct it by selective, out of context quoting; and fill in the blanks with insinuation you then ask me to clarify.

Note how you initially "asked about my public speculation", and change it to asking if I "still believe the assertion".

Speculation becomes assertion, but you seem to hope I won't notice.

Put down the goal posts.

[TSherbs]

... While I'm not suggesting TSherbs and EoC are the same person,....

Yeah, that would lower your batting average.

But I asked you about your public speculation (more than once) about Warbler as EOC.

Why spend this time explaining history to EOC when he would know it all already? Have you let go of your speculation that Warbler is EOC in disguise? Last you addressed this directly, you said that you were still waiting for Warbler to slip up.

Why do you obsess over constructing these narratives,

The "narrative" of asking you if you still believe the assertion that you made quite recently about the identity of a poster active here on this thread? That "narrative"?

You don't usually duck straightforward, easy questions, dneal. But how you post is your prerogative.

reprise

[dneal]

Reprise indeed, but you don't see the irony.

[TSherbs]

I'll make my position clear: I take Warbler at his word and do not assert or even suggest that he is the person behind the moniker EOC. I have seen no patterns in his posts or language or way of thinking that is similar to that demonstrated by EOC over the years of his presence here. I have never suggested anything to the contrary in any post here.

See how easy answering the question is?

[dneal]

I've made my position clear as well. You continue to misrepresent it with a narrative you've constructed.

I'm not obligated to entertain it.

See? I give you simple answers. They're just not the ones you are looking for.

[TSherbs]

cool

your prerogative